Decade-Long Study Reveals Female Stingrays Return to Same South African Site for Years
Marine Science

Decade-Long Study Reveals Female Stingrays Return to Same South African Site for Years

Researchers tracking short-tailed stingrays in Gansbaai used natural spot patterns to identify individual animals over a ten-year period.

By Divya Iyer
Published:
Email this Article

A decade-long marine study in Gansbaai, South Africa, has revealed that a small group of female short-tailed stingrays exhibits remarkable site fidelity, returning to the same coastal waters for up to ten years. Researchers tracked the animals using opportunistic photographs and vessel logs, uncovering new insights into the behavior of one of the world’s largest stingray species.

The short-tailed stingray (Bathytoshia brevicaudata), also known as the smooth stingray, can grow up to 210 centimeters in disk width. Despite their impressive size and wide distribution across the Southern Hemisphere, large coastal rays remain poorly understood and vulnerable to fishing pressures and habitat degradation. To learn more about their local habits, researchers analyzed sightings data gathered between 2014 and 2024 during commercial shark cage-diving operations at Joubertsdam, an inshore site near Gansbaai. The findings were published in Ecology and Evolution by R. G. A. Watson and A. J. Webber.

How Spot Patterns Revealed Individual Stingrays Over Ten Years

During 5,730 operational days across the eleven-year study period, vessel crews recorded 1,351 short-tailed stingray sightings across 1,149 separate trips. By examining unique pigmentation patterns and dorsal spot clusters behind the spiracles, the team successfully cataloged eleven individual stingrays. These natural markings remained stable and unchanged over multiple years, confirming that photographic identification is a reliable, non-invasive alternative to traditional tagging.

Among the identified animals, residency times varied dramatically. Some individuals appeared only once as transient visitors, while others demonstrated long-term loyalty to the area. For instance, an individual designated as STSR002 was sighted 156 times over a span stretching nearly a decade. Interestingly, nearly all identified stingrays were female, raising new questions about where male short-tailed stingrays spend their time.

Environmental Triggers and Shifting Predator Dynamics

Statistical modeling revealed that sea surface temperature and water depth strongly influence when these rays appear at the surface. Sighting probabilities increased significantly when water temperatures rose above 15 degrees Celsius, aligning with the thermal preferences of the species. Sightings peaked in waters between 6 and 9 meters deep, and followed a distinct bimodal seasonal pattern with higher numbers between March and July, and a secondary peak in September.

The team also noted a sustained increase in stingray sightings after 2017. This timeline coincides with the local disappearance of white sharks from the Gansbaai area and a corresponding rise in other marine species like bronze whaler sharks and sunfish. Because white sharks are known predators of large batoids, the researchers suggest that reduced predation pressure may have encouraged the stingrays to spend more time surfacing around cage-diving vessels.

Implications for Marine Conservation and Future Research

While the short-tailed stingray is currently categorized as Least Concern on the IUCN Red List, individuals face ongoing threats from commercial bycatch and recreational fishing. Traditional physical tagging programs in South Africa have historically suffered from extremely low recapture rates, often due to tag loss. The success of photographic identification at Joubertsdam demonstrates that ecotourism platforms can provide invaluable long-term monitoring data without stressing the animals.

Future research will need to determine whether the Gansbaai aggregation is linked to other known regional sites, such as Miller’s Point or Struisbaai. Deploying acoustic telemetry and expanding photographic databases to neighboring coastal areas will be essential steps for building a comprehensive management plan for these vulnerable marine vertebrates.

The research was published in Ecology and evolution on November 17, 2026.

Fact Checked

This article has been fact checked for accuracy, with information verified against reputable sources. Learn more about us and our editorial process.

Last reviewed on .

Article history

  • Latest version

Reference(s)

  1. Watson, R. G. A.., et al. “Long‐Term Site Fidelity and Environmental Drivers of Short‐Tailed Stingray ( Bathytoshia brevicaudata ) Occurrence in South Africa: Evidence From Decade‐Scale Sightings Data and Photo‐Identification.” Ecology and Evolution, vol. 16, no. 11, November 17, 2026 Wiley, doi: 10.1002/ece3.74645. <https://doi.org/10.1002/ece3.74645>.

Cite this page:

Iyer, Divya. “Decade-Long Study Reveals Female Stingrays Return to Same South African Site for Years.” BioScience. BioScience ISSN 2521-5760, 20 November 2026. <https://www.bioscience.com.pk/en/subject/marine-science/long-term-site-fidelity-and-environmental-drivers-of-short-tailed-stingray-lt-i-gt-bathytoshia-brevicaudata-lt-i-gt-occurrence-in-south-africa-evidence-from-decade-scale-sightings-data-and-photo-identification>. Iyer, D. (2026, November 20). “Decade-Long Study Reveals Female Stingrays Return to Same South African Site for Years.” BioScience. ISSN 2521-5760. Retrieved November 20, 2026 from https://www.bioscience.com.pk/en/subject/marine-science/long-term-site-fidelity-and-environmental-drivers-of-short-tailed-stingray-lt-i-gt-bathytoshia-brevicaudata-lt-i-gt-occurrence-in-south-africa-evidence-from-decade-scale-sightings-data-and-photo-identification Iyer, Divya. “Decade-Long Study Reveals Female Stingrays Return to Same South African Site for Years.” BioScience. ISSN 2521-5760. https://www.bioscience.com.pk/en/subject/marine-science/long-term-site-fidelity-and-environmental-drivers-of-short-tailed-stingray-lt-i-gt-bathytoshia-brevicaudata-lt-i-gt-occurrence-in-south-africa-evidence-from-decade-scale-sightings-data-and-photo-identification (accessed November 20, 2026).
End of the article