Why Homeless Pet Owners Face an Impossible Choice Across the UK
New qualitative research reveals how pet-inclusive accommodation policies impact mental health, housing access, and animal welfare across England, Wales, and Scotland.
Up to a quarter of people experiencing homelessness in the UK face a heart-wrenching choice between losing their shelter or giving up their beloved companion animal. While between 5 and 25 percent of unhoused individuals own a pet, very few temporary accommodation services permit dogs or cats, creating a massive barrier to stability. A qualitative study published in PLOS One explores how pet-inclusive policies are viewed, implemented, and experienced across the UK homelessness sector.
What Did the Study Reveal About the Human-Pet Bond?
Researchers conducted semi-structured interviews with 36 participants across England, Wales, and Scotland between September 2024 and March 2025. The sample included 13 individuals with lived experience of homelessness, 21 accommodation service staff, and two service commissioners. The analysis identified six major themes, highlighting both the profound emotional distress caused by forced pet separation and the positive impacts of pet-inclusive housing.
Participants experiencing homelessness described the search for pet-friendly housing as arduous and distressing. Many recounted feeling stigmatized and dehumanized when staff minimized the deep emotional bond they shared with their animals. For those forced to surrender their pets, the experience brought intense grief and guilt, compounding the trauma of losing their homes, possessions, and livelihoods.
How Do Shared Buildings and Staff Resources Impact Pet Policies?
The study found that physical infrastructure and staffing levels heavily dictated whether a facility could accept pets. A general shortage of affordable housing across the UK narrows options for everyone, but adding a pet into the equation creates an even tighter bottleneck. Many providers expressed reluctance to allow pets in House in Multiple Occupation shared accommodation, citing concerns over cramped communal spaces, hygiene, and potential conflicts.
However, staff and residents in pet-inclusive shared settings challenged this assumption. They reported that with clear boundaries, sensible risk assessments, and pragmatically designed pet policies, housing animals safely in shared spaces was entirely achievable. Furthermore, these environments often fostered a stronger sense of community among residents.
What Drives Staff Attitudes and Decision-Making?
Because property owners, housing associations, and private landlords hold ultimate decision-making power, pet acceptance often relied on arbitrary factors. The presence of a single staff member with a strong personal affinity for animals frequently proved crucial in helping a service adopt a pet-inclusive policy. Staff in pet-inclusive services viewed supporting the human-animal bond as an integral part of trauma-informed care rather than an administrative burden.
While some staff members initially feared increased workloads, hygiene issues, or aggressive behavior, those working in pet-inclusive facilities emphasized that such incidents were rare and easily managed. They noted that retention rates among vulnerable residents actually increased when individuals were allowed to keep their pets, as the animals provided a vital sense of daily purpose and emotional grounding.
What Are the Limits and What Happens Next?
Despite the overwhelming benefits, the authors noted several limitations in their work. Because most participants were recruited through practice partner networks, the sample likely skewed toward individuals who already held positive views on pet-inclusion. Only three staff members from non-pet-inclusive services participated, meaning opposing viewpoints were less represented.
The authors suggest that policymakers should adopt a default position of pet-inclusion, particularly in emergency and first-line accommodation, unless a clear risk assessment dictates otherwise. Standardized guidance, staff training, and stronger partnerships with veterinary charities could help dismantle lingering barriers, ensuring that vulnerable people no longer have to choose between a safe roof over their heads and their most loyal companion.
The research was published in PLOS One on November 18, 2026.
This article has been fact checked for accuracy, with information verified against reputable sources. Learn more about us and our editorial process.
Last reviewed on .
Article history
- Latest version
Reference(s)
- Brown, Steven., et al. ““If having a dog housed with somebody means that we save one life, then give the dog a home”: A qualitative study exploring how pet-inclusive policies are viewed, implemented and experienced in UK homelessness accommodation services.” PLOS One, vol. 21, no. 11, November 18, 2026, pp. e0355861 Public Library of Science (PLoS), doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0355861. <https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0355861>.
Cite this page:
- Posted by David Anderson