Why Convicted Men in South Africa Commit Gender-Based Violence
A comprehensive review suggests that historical inequality, childhood trauma, and biological factors intertwine to drive high rates of violence.
Decades after the end of apartheid, South African men convicted of gender-based violence are shaped by an interconnected web of social history, childhood trauma, and biology, according to a new synthesis of past research.
Gender-based violence remains a persistent global crisis, but South Africa faces exceptionally severe levels that have persisted despite the introduction of progressive legislation and broad legal reforms. A team of researchers set out to untangle why rates remain so high by examining the root causes of violent behavior among convicted men in the country. Their work is available in the International journal of prison health, offering a comprehensive look at the forces driving these offenses.
How History and Patriarchal Norms Shape Modern Violence
The review highlights that South Africa’s high rates of violence are deeply rooted in historical policies, including colonialism and apartheid, which devastated indigenous family structures and entrenched rigid patriarchal values. The authors note that colonial authorities concentrated formal education and employment on men, establishing a social norm where a man’s identity became tied to his role as an economic provider and his authority over women and children. When economic hardship or widespread unemployment prevents men from meeting these traditional expectations, the resulting crisis of identity can trigger aggressive behavior as an alternative means of asserting dominance.
While laws and police statistics document thousands of reported rapes and assaults each year, criminal justice interventions often fail because they punish acts of violence without addressing the underlying sociocultural frameworks that sustain them. Traditional gender norms continue to equate masculinity with toughness, sexual entitlement, and control, creating an environment where violence is normalized from an early age.
The Psychological Toll of Childhood Adversity
Beyond broad social pressures, the psychological profiles of convicted offenders often reveal deep-seated developmental wounds. Researchers found that early-life exposure to domestic violence, maltreatment, and harsh physical discipline disrupts healthy attachment styles and impairs emotional regulation. Growing up in chaotic or violent households can hinder a person’s capacity to mentalize, which is the ability to understand one’s own and others’ mental states and emotional intentions.
Because prevailing cultural norms teach men to suppress vulnerable emotions while permitting anger, emotional distress is frequently channeled through aggression. Substance abuse acts as a major catalyst within this dynamic, as heavy drinking in informal settlements and social taverns lowers behavioral inhibition and fuels volatile confrontations.
Biological Vulnerabilities and Environmental Triggers
Biological factors also contribute to aggressive tendencies, though the authors caution that much of this data stems from international studies rather than local cohorts. Genetic variations, such as low-activity alleles of the monoamine oxidase-A gene, interact with adverse caregiving environments to elevate the risk of antisocial behavior. Similarly, neurotransmitters like serotonin and dopamine, along with hormones such as testosterone, influence impulse control and reward-seeking behaviors.
Traumatic brain injuries were also identified as a significant predictor of intimate partner violence, often resulting in executive functioning deficits and chronic anger management challenges. However, the authors stress that biological risks do not operate in a vacuum. Instead, they interact dynamically with poverty, stress, and cultural expectations, meaning that physical vulnerabilities are more likely to manifest as violence when amplified by a hostile environment.
What These Findings Mean for Future Rehabilitation
The authors conclude that effective intervention strategies must move beyond purely punitive measures to adopt holistic, trauma-informed care within correctional facilities. By screening offenders for biological head injuries, addressing developmental trauma, and challenging harmful masculine norms, healthcare providers and policymakers may better reduce recidivism and foster lasting behavioral change.
The research was published in International journal of prison health on November 20, 2026.
This article has been fact checked for accuracy, with information verified against reputable sources. Learn more about us and our editorial process.
Last reviewed on .
Article history
- Latest version
Cite this page:
- Posted by Elizabeth Taylor