Why Millions Of Americans Are Trading Retail Circulars For Creator Posts This Holiday Season
Half of US adults purchased holiday gifts based on creator recommendations last year, with trends suggesting even higher engagement for the upcoming season.
The New Holiday Shopping Paradigm: Why Consumers Are Turning to Creators Over Traditional Retailers
The traditional holiday shopping journey, once dictated by printed catalogs and mass-market retail circulars, has shifted decisively toward social media feeds. A recent analysis from the Center for the Creator Economy reveals that for a vast majority of American adults, the process of selecting gifts now begins with a saved post from an online creator.
According to the center’s second industry flash report, 77% of U.S. adults actively curate lists of potential presents by saving content from creators. This trend is particularly pronounced among women and individuals between the ages of 18 and 44. These digital bookmarks are primarily housed on Instagram (60%), YouTube (59%), and TikTok (53%).
The survey, which polled 988 U.S. adults in November 2026, highlights that this digital curation is translating directly into commerce. Half of all respondents reported purchasing at least one gift recommended by a creator during the previous holiday season, with significant activity occurring during major retail windows like Black Friday and Cyber Monday. Looking ahead, consumer intent remains high, with 61% of adults indicating they are likely to follow creator recommendations for their holiday shopping this year. That likelihood jumps to 85% among shoppers who have successfully used creator recommendations in the past.
Ryan Schram, executive director of the Center for the Creator Economy, notes that the shift represents a fundamental change in how influence functions in the modern retail landscape. “Holiday shopping used to start with a store circular or a retailer’s email. Now, for most Americans, it starts with a saved post,” Schram explains. He suggests that the effectiveness of these influencers lies in their perceived utility, even when consumers are fully aware of the commercial nature of the content.
Trust and Transparency in the Creator Economy
While creators are cementing their role as essential shopping guides, the landscape of trust remains complex. Personal networks still command the highest level of confidence, with 75% of consumers placing their faith in recommendations from friends and family. However, creators are rapidly gaining ground, currently matching brands in consumer trust and significantly outperforming artificial intelligence tools and celebrity endorsements.
As the holiday season progresses, the influence of creators is being felt most strongly across specific product categories, including:
- Beauty and personal care
- Clothing and accessories
- Electronics
- Home and kitchen goods
This article has been fact checked for accuracy, with information verified against reputable sources. Learn more about us and our editorial process.
Last reviewed on .
Article history
- Latest version
Reference(s)
- “Industry Flash Reports - Center for the Creator Economy | Syracuse University – Syracuse University.” <https://creatoreconomy.syracuse.edu/research-and-intelligence/industry-flash-reports/?_gl=1*h88zqf*_gcl_au*MTE5ODE1MjM5NS4xNzk0MjQwMDEy*_ga*OTgzMDk1ODY3LjE3MTk5MjgyMDY.*_ga_QT13NN6N9S*czE3OTUxOTE4NjkkbzEyNSRnMSR0MTc5NTE5MjczMiRqNTkkbDAkaDA.*_ga_SRVN5YVLB5*czE3OTUxOTE4NjkkbzUzJGcxJHQxNzk1MTkxODg1JGo0NCRsMCRoMA..*_ga_65S0N1FWNY*czE3OTUxOTE4NzAkbzE1NiRnMSR0MTc5NTE5MTg4NSRqNDUkbDAkaDA.*_ga_S5CXSPXYHM*czE3OTUxOTE4NzEkbzE4JGcxJHQxNzk1MTkxODg1JGo0NiRsMCRoMA..>.
Cite this page:
- Posted by James Whitmore