Why Large-Scale Medical Data Sharing Might Face a Fundamental Dead End
Biotechnology

Why Large-Scale Medical Data Sharing Might Face a Fundamental Dead End

New research suggests that connecting hospital computer networks faces deep contextual and structural barriers that current standards cannot easily fix.

By Rohan Kumar
Published:
Email this Article
Why Large-Scale Medical Data Sharing Might Face a Fundamental Dead End
Photo by Sharad Bhat on Unsplash

Health data accounts for more than 30% of the world’s data assets, yet less than 3% of that information is actively utilized. Connecting different medical computer networks to freely share this clinical information is often treated as a simple technical fix, but new research suggests that large-scale sharing between electronic health record systems might face fundamental barriers.

The study, published in JMIR Medical Informatics in November 2026 by researchers Fredrik Öberg and Sebastiaan Meijer from Karolinska University Hospital and the KTH Royal Institute of Technology, evaluates what happens when healthcare networks attempt system-system interoperability. By looking at a real-world project in Stockholm alongside historical definitions dating back to 1991, the authors argue that current assumptions about data sharing may be overly optimistic.

Why Connecting Medical Networks is Harder Than It Looks

Efforts to unite medical databases typically rely on system-system interoperability, meaning separate technical applications exchange operational data directly or through intermediate platforms. Proponents assume that once medical data moves between systems, it functions seamlessly in the receiving software. However, the authors point out that medical information depends heavily on deep contextual details that external technology cannot easily capture.

During a preoperative assessment project linking six hospitals in the Stockholm municipality area starting in 2017, participating clinicians managed to share 19 data types between operation planning systems and a common electronic health record system. Yet, they had to exclude standard metrics like blood pressure because local measurement workflows and hospital practices varied too much. Without extensive manual harmonization and workshops, doctors risked misinterpreting the numbers, which could lead to potential patient safety issues.

The Limits of Semantic Standards in Clinical Settings

A major pillar of modern data-sharing proposals involves relying on external semantic standards, such as standardized terminologies and coding vocabularies like the Systematized Nomenclature of Medicine Clinical Terms, known as SNOMED CT. The idea is that attaching standardized concept identifiers to patient records guarantees a shared understanding across different hospitals and countries. The new analysis challenges this assumption, noting that external standards act as coordination tools requiring continuous local interpretation rather than acting as neutral carriers of universal meaning.

Even highly expressive terminologies are intentionally context-agnostic to remain broadly reusable, which strips away critical situational information. Crucial clinical subtleties, such as the training level of personnel, the precise equipment used, the exact reason for logging a measurement, or the broader care process, are routinely lost. Furthermore, unlike technical standards such as USB connectors where users adapt physical practices to fit the plug, health data standards must conform to varied clinical workflows, creating inevitable gaps that require ongoing local workarounds.

Can Shared Data Become Operational in New Systems?

Another core expectation of system-system interoperability is that imported data will become fully operational in the receiving software, feeding into local data models, algorithms, and decision-support tools. Most contemporary electronic health record systems are built to handle operational data originating exclusively from their own user interfaces or directly connected devices. Treating externally sourced records as first-class operational data introduces unresolved questions regarding data provenance, trust, legal liability, and user comprehension.

When external data enters a foreign system, distinguishing it from locally generated records poses serious user interface design challenges. Automated algorithms trained on local hospital conditions might misinterpret data gathered under different clinical environments. The authors emphasize that these hurdles cannot be resolved simply by adding external software components, such as those proposed in the European Health Data Space legislation, without a massive internal redesign of hospital information architecture.

What Lies Ahead for Digital Health Policy

The analysis indicates that semantic standardization cannot fully stabilize data meaning, multidirectional sharing cannot easily serve as the primary mechanism for operational hospital workflows, and current approaches lack scalability across multiple actors and systems. The researchers suggest that large-scale programs should not proceed on unexamined assumptions of seamless data mobility. Instead, policymakers should reposition interoperability as a contested sociotechnical object of critical inquiry and consider using more specific descriptive terms like referential access or read-only portals to prevent unmet expectations.

The research was published in JMIR medical informatics on November 13, 2026.

Fact Checked

This article has been fact checked for accuracy, with information verified against reputable sources. Learn more about us and our editorial process.

Last reviewed on .

Article history

  • Latest version

Reference(s)

  1. Öberg, Fredrik., et al. “Interoperability Between Health Information Systems: Dead End in Large-Scale Sharing of Health Data?.” JMIR Medical Informatics, vol. 14, November 13, 2026, pp. e105089-e105089. JMIR Publications Inc., doi: 10.2196/105089. <https://doi.org/10.2196/105089>.

Cite this page:

Kumar, Rohan. “Why Large-Scale Medical Data Sharing Might Face a Fundamental Dead End.” BioScience. BioScience ISSN 2521-5760, 15 November 2026. <https://www.bioscience.com.pk/en/subject/biotechnology/interoperability-between-health-information-systems-dead-end-in-large-scale-sharing-of-health-data>. Kumar, R. (2026, November 15). “Why Large-Scale Medical Data Sharing Might Face a Fundamental Dead End.” BioScience. ISSN 2521-5760. Retrieved November 15, 2026 from https://www.bioscience.com.pk/en/subject/biotechnology/interoperability-between-health-information-systems-dead-end-in-large-scale-sharing-of-health-data Kumar, Rohan. “Why Large-Scale Medical Data Sharing Might Face a Fundamental Dead End.” BioScience. ISSN 2521-5760. https://www.bioscience.com.pk/en/subject/biotechnology/interoperability-between-health-information-systems-dead-end-in-large-scale-sharing-of-health-data (accessed November 15, 2026).
End of the article