Ancient DNA Reveals the Exact Cuttlefish Species Eaten by 19th-Century Chinese Migrants
Genetic testing of fragile cuttlebone fragments from western American archaeological sites shows that migrants imported specific Asian cephalopods rather than buying local Mediterranean options.
Ancient DNA extracted from 35 fragile, porous marine fragments recovered across five late nineteenth- to early twentieth-century Chinese diaspora sites in California, Oregon, Utah, and Wyoming reveals that immigrant communities imported specific Asian cuttlefish species over more accessible Mediterranean varieties. Cuttlefishes, belonging to the family Sepiidae within the class Cephalopoda and phylum Mollusca, possess a unique internal buoyancy-regulating shell called a cuttlebone or sepion. Because these robust dorsal structures made of aragonite and beta-chitin frequently survive in archaeological contexts, they represent the most common cephalopod remains found in North American Chinese diaspora deposits, yet traditional morphological identification is notoriously difficult due to fragmentation.
How Researchers Extracted Genetic Secrets From Fragile Cuttlebones
To bypass the morphological barriers caused by weathering and breaking, researchers carried out ancient DNA analyses on specimens from the Arboretum Chinese Labor Quarters, Aspen Section Camp, Jacksonville Chinese Quarter, Terrace Chinatown, and The Dalles Chinatown. All pre-polymerase chain reaction procedures were performed inside a dedicated clean laboratory utilizing positive pressure and HEPA air filtration. The authors published the findings in Royal Society Open Science, detailing how decontaminated cuttlebone fragments were crushed or lysed whole using proteinase k and EDTA before purification via silica-spin columns.
Amplification targeted mitochondrial markers, specifically the cytochrome c oxidase subunit I and 12S ribosomal RNA genes, because they possess broad taxonomic coverage in reference databases. Out of the 35 analysed fragments, 27 successfully yielded amplifiable mitochondrial DNA, representing a success rate of 77.1 percent. Stringent negative controls and duplicate sequencing steps confirmed the authenticity of the genetic data and ruled out modern contamination.
Golden, Kisslip, and Japanese Spineless Species Revealed in the American West
Sanger sequencing and phylogenetic maximum-likelihood trees demonstrated the presence of three distinct cuttlefish species across the western sites. The golden cuttlefish (Acanthosepion esculentum) made up 59.3 percent of the successfully identified specimens, while the kisslip cuttlefish (Acanthosepion lycidas) and the Japanese spineless cuttlefish (Sepiella japonica) accounted for 22.2 percent and 18.5 percent, respectively. All three taxa inhabit coastal waters in East and Southeast Asia, including the coastal zones of Guangdong Province, where many nineteenth-century migrants originated.
The identification of these specific Asian marine taxa points directly to historical transnational trade networks operated by Hong Kong-based merchant firms known as jinshanzhuang. Historical cargo records from steamships crossing the Pacific frequently listed dried marine goods, including cuttlefish, imported to feed and supply overseas Chinese workers. Furthermore, the absence of cuttlefish species native to Australia or the Mediterranean Sea aligns with historical accounts indicating that consumers preferred familiar foodstuffs from their homeland to maintain cultural connections and identity.
DNA Preservation Limits and Next Steps for Archaeological Science
Amplification success varied widely between sites, ranging from over 90 percent at the Arboretum Chinese Labor Quarters down to 50 percent or lower at other locations, highlighting the challenges of working with degraded ancient biomolecules. The high porosity of the cuttlebone lamellar matrix likely leaves DNA vulnerable to microbial decay and chemical degradation over more than a century of burial. Moreover, reference sequence gaps and occasional misidentifications in public repositories continue to complicate genetic wildlife tracking.
The authors suggest that future investigations should adopt high-throughput sequencing technologies capable of recovering shorter, highly fragmented DNA strands from fragile invertebrate remains. Expanding reference databases with vouchered museum specimens will also sharpen future faunal analyses. Ultimately, applying genetic screening to cuttlebone collections across global archaeological contexts promises to illuminate historic human-ocean interactions on a worldwide scale.
The research was published in Royal Society open science on November 18, 2026.
This article has been fact checked for accuracy, with information verified against reputable sources. Learn more about us and our editorial process.
Last reviewed on .
Article history
- Latest version
Reference(s)
- Royle, Thomas C. A.., et al. “Ancient DNA analysis of archaeological cuttlebones from Chinese diaspora sites provides insight into historical cuttlefish (Sepiidae) trade.” Royal Society Open Science, vol. 13, no. 11, November 18, 2026 The Royal Society, doi: 10.1098/rsos.261529. <https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.261529>.
Cite this page:
- Posted by Kamran Akhtar